My rating: 3 of 5 stars
I’d originally read this book closer to it’s original publication (which was around two or three years ago), and for whatever reason, I remember liking it more than I do now. I don’t know if it’s because I’ve read the same cliches so many more times since then, but this book (this series, really) is so stereotypical, that I could’t get past how annoying it really was the second time around.
I’ll admit that I did enjoy the first two books–cliches aside–and even rated them fairly well, but man, this last book underwhelmed me, and honestly, if I hadn’t already known the series continued with The Becoming of Noah Shaw, I would have probably hated the ending more.
Why did I feel this way?
Because the first two books seemed to have all this build up, all this mystery, that promised what would be some very interesting answers, but when the answers came, seriously, I was so disappointed by how unfulfilling they were. They were revelations, sure, but I personally thought them stupid, and oh-so-typical of YA, in the sense of needing to make things more “tragic” than necessary…more “over the top”, so that our emotions will be more invested. Well, I’m pretty sure the emotions the author was hoping for probably weren’t annoyance and disappointment, but that could just be me, and I can’t speak for the general population.
Anyway, what else could I mention…? There was a good amount of purple prose that I was okay with initially, but started disliking when events and the people involved in them started annoying me. Because they’re tied up with spoilers, I won’t pinpoint particular moments, but let’s just say there were moments where I was rolling my eyes, or cringing at the cheesy, overly flowery writing…
At this point, what did I like? Right? I liked friendships…I liked getting answers (even if the answers themselves sucked)…and…?? I think I’ll just end it there, since I’m not sure there’s really much more for me to mention, in regards to things I actually liked.
If I was going to rate the trilogy as a whole, I’d probably rate it a 3.5, because of my liking the first two well enough, but as a whole, I don’t really like it all that much, so on that note, not one I will be personally recommending.